Xbox Ally X: New Xbox-Branded Handheld Console Xbox

[David76]

The Asus ROG Xbox Ally X has made strides in acknowledging a crucial reality in the handheld gaming market: Windows 11 struggles as a handheld operating system. The device transitions away from the traditional desktop interface to a more gamepad-optimised 'Xbox' mode, which provides improved accessibility to games and launchers. While this is a welcome change, it doesn't compensate for the device's many shortcomings.

At a price point of £800 ($1000), the ROG Xbox Ally X's performance is inconsistent. Despite ergonomic improvements in its design, including better grips and improved rumble feedback on triggers, it suffers from critical issues such as a subpar D-pad and noisy face buttons. The internal vibration motors also exhibit reliability issues, occasionally failing during gameplay.

The display, while decent at 1920x1080 resolution, is less impressive than its predecessor, showing reduced brightness and colour reproduction. In terms of gaming performance, the Ally X does rival other handhelds but fails to establish itself as a next-gen device. Battery life remains mediocre, especially compared to competitors like the Steam Deck.

While the 'Xbox' mode enhances the user experience by simplifying navigation, it doesn't significantly improve gaming performance or battery efficiency. Furthermore, the interface often struggles to recognise inputs, making for a frustrating user experience.

While the Asus ROG Xbox Ally X showcases innovative design and software improvements, it ultimately falls short of expectations. Potential buyers may want to hold off until further updates address these concerns.

Key Points:

• The ROG Xbox Ally X introduces a gamepad-optimised 'Xbox' mode.
• Priced at £800 ($1000), it faces stiff competition in performance and battery life.
• Ergonomic design and features like improved triggers are overshadowed by build quality issues.
• The display is less vibrant than its predecessor, affecting the overall experience.
• Gaming performance is competitive, but not revolutionary compared to rivals.
• Users may experience input recognition issues in 'Xbox' mode.

 

[Tom]

Eurogamer review (summarised), full review link below..

The ROG Xbox Ally X has emerged as a noteworthy player in the realm of handheld gaming devices. This review delves into its features, capabilities, and how it compares to established competitors, particularly the Steam Deck, while exploring whether it truly fits within the Xbox ecosystem.

Overview of the ROG Xbox Ally X
The ROG Xbox Ally X presents itself as a powerful handheld gaming PC, designed with aesthetics reminiscent of Xbox consoles. It delivers a robust gaming experience, utilizing both the Xbox (PC) store and Game Pass, alongside other major gaming platforms like Steam, Epic, and more. This versatility allows users to switch between console-like gaming and traditional PC setups seamlessly.

User Experience and Interface
One of the defining aspects of the ROG Xbox Ally X is its Xbox fullscreen experience, which aims to provide a more streamlined, console-like interface by obscuring the underlying Windows operating system. This design choice is commendable, as it fosters an environment that feels more akin to a dedicated handheld console. However, it is not without its imperfections, as there are instances where the Windows interface rears its head, breaking the immersion.

The Xbox (PC) store integration is a highlight, offering a familiar UI for those accustomed to Xbox consoles. Yet, the limitations of the Play Anywhere initiative become apparent, as not all Xbox games are compatible with the PC store. This can lead to disappointment for users expecting a comprehensive library of titles.

Performance and Game Compatibility
The ROG Xbox Ally X supports a variety of games, but its performance can vary significantly from title to title. Some games, particularly those marked as Handheld Optimised, run exceptionally well, providing smooth, enjoyable gameplay. Titles such as "Gears of War: Reloaded" and "Indiana Jones and the Great Circle" demonstrate the device's capability to handle demanding graphics while maintaining a solid frame rate.

However, many Xbox-published games fall into the "Mostly Compatible" category, which may require users to make adjustments for optimal performance. This inconsistency could be frustrating for players expecting a plug-and-play experience. Furthermore, the lack of an OLED screen may deter some potential buyers, especially those who have become accustomed to that technology.

Build Quality and Design
The ROG Xbox Ally X boasts an attractive design, characterized by its comfortable form factor reminiscent of Xbox controllers. This ergonomic design enhances the overall gaming experience, making extended play sessions more enjoyable. However, at a price point of around £800, the lack of included accessories such as a carrying case feels like a missed opportunity, given that even lower-priced competitors offer such essentials.

Final Thoughts: Is it an Xbox?
The question of whether the ROG Xbox Ally X qualifies as an Xbox is nuanced. While it operates within the Xbox ecosystem and offers access to a wide array of games, it fundamentally remains a PC at its core. This distinction presents both advantages and challenges, particularly regarding game compatibility and user interface consistency.

Ultimately, the ROG Xbox Ally X is not merely a handheld console but a hybrid device that caters to both console and PC gamers. For those who value flexibility and performance in their gaming experience, it represents a compelling option, though it may not fully satisfy users seeking the traditional Xbox console experience.

Summary of Key Points:

• The ROG Xbox Ally X combines features of a powerful handheld PC with Xbox console aesthetics.
• Offers a unique Xbox fullscreen experience, but can occasionally reveal its Windows roots.
• Performance varies by title, with some games requiring manual adjustments for optimal play.
• Ergonomic design provides comfort for extended gaming sessions, but lacks included accessories.
• Represents a versatile gaming option, appealing to both console and PC enthusiasts, though it may not fully align with traditional Xbox expectations.

ROG Xbox Ally X review - an impressive handheld PC wearing an Xbox mask

Eurogamer's review of the new ROG Xbox Ally X gaming handheld that attempts to combine the ease of Xbox with the versatility of Windows.

www.eurogamer.net